Lung Cancer Medical Negligence Neglecting to Address Risk Factors
LUNG CANCER MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE MISCOMMUNICATION BETWEEN MEDICAL TEAMS IN LUNG CANCER
John Whelan Solicitor with specialist expertise in Lung Cancer Medical Negligence gives an example of failure in Miscommunication Between Medical Teams in Lung Cancer.
Case Example: Neglecting to Address Risk Factors in Lung Cancer
Patient Background:
A Patient with a smoking history presents to GP with complaints of a persistent cough and shortness of breath. They also report some unexplained weight loss over the past two months, as well as occasional chest pain. The Patient had given up smoking 10 years ago, and is otherwise healthy, with no significant medical history other than mild hypertension, which is well controlled with medication.
The Patient is retired, living alone, and does not have a family history of lung cancer or other cancers. Despite their past smoking history, the Patient has not previously undergone any lung cancer screenings.
Initial Evaluation and Risk Factor Neglect:
The GP performs a routine physical examination and listens to the Patient’s lungs, noting mild wheezing. Given that the Patient is an ex smoker, the GP attributes the symptoms to chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) or smoking related lung damage. No imaging tests, such as chest Xray or CT scan, are ordered initially. The Patient is prescribed a bronchodilator and is encouraged to continue managing blood pressure but is not referred for further investigation or screening for lung cancer.
Over the following month, the Patient's symptoms worsen. The cough becomes more persistent, and they begin to experience more severe shortness of breath and fatigue, which limits daily activities. The Patient returns to the GP, but once again, the symptoms are attributed to COPD exacerbation rather than being investigated for a possible malignant cause.
Missed Diagnosis and Delayed Testing:
Despite the progressive nature of the Patient's symptoms, the GP does not pursue any diagnostic imaging. Only after the Patient experiences a severe coughing episode, leading to coughing up blood, does the GP refers them for a chest Xray, which shows a mass in the left lung. A CT scan is then ordered, confirming a large tumour in the left lung. The biopsy reveals non small cell lung cancer specifically adenocarcinoma.
By the time the diagnosis is made, the tumour has already reached stage III, and surgical resection is no longer an option. The Patient begins chemotherapy and radiation, but the prognosis is poor, and quality of life is significantly impacted by the side effects of treatment.
Issues:
Failure to Address Smoking History as a Major Risk Factor: Despite the Patient's smoking history, the GP failed to consider lung cancer as a possible cause of the Patient's symptoms, choosing instead to attribute them to COPD or smoking related lung damage.
Lack of Screening or Imaging: In a high risk Patient (ex-smoker with persistent symptoms), a chest Xray or CT scan should have been ordered early in the Patient’s care. Lung cancer screening, especially for individuals with significant smoking histories, is recommended, and the absence of such testing led to a delay in diagnosis.
Missed Early Detection Opportunity: Lung cancer can often be more treatable when detected at an earlier stage. The delay in diagnosis meant that the Patient’s tumour was too large and advanced for surgery, limiting treatment options.
Important Points
Risk Factor Awareness.
Early Imaging for High Risk Patients.
Lung Cancer Screening Guidelines.
What should have been done
a) Routine Screening for High Risk Patients.
b) Proactive Investigation of Symptoms.
c) Smoker’s Cessation Support.
For more detailed insights into how the Patient Safety Act 2023 impacts you and how Whelan Law can support you, please visit our Lung Cancer Medical Negligence https://www.whelanlaw.ie/news/rising-lung-cancer-medical-negligence-claims-a-reflection-of-modern-medicine/